Planting trees is an investment in the future. Whether you’re a professional landscaper or a first-time gardener, choosing the right tool is critical for the health of your trees and the ease of your work. Two common tools often confuse even experienced planters: the digging spade and the shovel. On the surface, they look similar, but their differences can make or break your tree-planting results. This article will give you a complete, practical comparison of digging spades and shovels for planting trees, backed by real-world examples, expert insights, and clear advice. By the end, you’ll know exactly which tool to pick for your specific situation—and why it matters.
Understanding The Tools: Digging Spade And Shovel
Before comparing, it’s important to define what each tool is and how it is designed.
What Is A Digging Spade?
A digging spade is a garden tool with a flat, rectangular blade and a straight or slightly curved edge. The blade is usually made from strong steel and is mounted to a long, straight handle (wood, fiberglass, or metal). The design allows for precise cuts through soil with minimal disturbance to the surrounding area.
Key features:
- Flat, straight blade for clean cuts
- Long, straight handle for leverage
- Often has a tread on top of the blade for foot pressure
Digging spades excel in tasks where you need to create straight, neat edges—like digging planting holes for trees or edging garden beds.
What Is A Shovel?
A shovel typically has a curved, rounded, or pointed blade with a scoop shape. The blade is deeper than a spade’s, designed to move loose material (like soil, sand, or gravel). The handle may be straight or D-shaped, and sometimes it is shorter than a spade’s.
Key features:
- Curved or pointed blade for scooping
- Deep bowl for carrying material
- Handles designed for lifting and moving
Shovels are great for moving bulk soil, mixing compost, or transferring mulch. They are not designed for clean, deep cuts into compacted ground.
Design Differences: Spade Vs Shovel
Understanding the physical differences helps you see why each tool performs differently.
| Feature | Digging Spade | Shovel |
|---|---|---|
| Blade Shape | Flat, straight edge | Curved/rounded or pointed |
| Blade Depth | Shallow, thin | Deep, bowl-shaped |
| Handle | Long, straight | Shorter, sometimes D-shaped |
| Purpose | Cutting, digging, edging | Scooping, moving material |
These differences mean that each tool has unique strengths and weaknesses.
How Each Tool Works When Planting Trees
The process of planting a tree usually involves digging a hole, removing soil, and sometimes shaping the edges or moving heavy soil. Let’s look at how each tool performs in each stage.
Digging The Hole
A digging spade is designed to cut through turf, roots, and compacted soil. Its flat blade slices neatly, letting you control the size and depth of the planting hole. This is especially important for young trees, which need the correct hole shape for healthy root spread.
A shovel, with its curved blade, is less efficient at making clean, straight cuts. It often creates uneven holes and struggles with dense or rooty soil.
Removing Soil
Here, the shovel takes the lead. Its deep bowl scoops and lifts soil quickly, making it easy to clear the hole. The spade can remove soil, but its flat blade holds less, so it’s slower for this task.
Shaping The Hole
Tree roots need space to spread. The spade allows you to make vertical sides and a flat bottom—ideal for root growth. A shovel leaves sloped, uneven sides, which can cause the tree to settle incorrectly.
Backfilling And Finishing
When refilling the hole around the tree roots, a shovel helps move large amounts of soil quickly. The spade is better for patting and firming the soil, ensuring no air pockets remain.
When To Use A Digging Spade For Planting Trees
In most tree-planting situations, a digging spade is the tool of choice for the following reasons:
- Precision: The flat blade gives you control, so your planting hole has straight sides and a uniform bottom. This helps the tree establish roots evenly.
- Root Protection: If you encounter roots from nearby trees or shrubs, the spade can slice through them cleanly, minimizing damage.
- Turf Removal: If you need to cut through grass or weeds, the spade’s sharp edge lifts turf in neat sections.
- Edging: For trees planted near lawns or garden beds, the spade creates a clean edge, which looks professional and helps with maintenance.
Non-obvious insight: Most beginners don’t realize that the shape of the planting hole affects long-term root growth. Holes with vertical sides, made by a spade, prevent “root circling”—when roots grow in a circle and strangle the tree.
Credit: www.amazon.com
When A Shovel Is Better For Planting Trees
While spades are usually best for digging, shovels are valuable in the following situations:
- Moving Loose Soil: After the hole is dug, shovels move large amounts of soil away efficiently.
- Backfilling: Shovels help you quickly refill holes around the tree once it’s in place.
- Dealing with Loose or Sandy Soil: In loose, sandy, or already-soft soil, the shovel’s shape allows for faster work.
- Mixing Amendments: If you need to mix compost, fertilizer, or mulch into the soil, the shovel’s bowl shape is ideal.
Non-obvious insight: Some beginners try to use a shovel for every stage, but this often leads to poorly shaped holes or even injury from overexertion, since shovels can be harder to force into compacted soil.
Which Tool Is More Ergonomic?
The comfort and safety of your hands, back, and shoulders matter, especially when planting many trees.
Spade Ergonomics
- Leverage: The long handle and foot treads mean you use your body weight, not just arm strength.
- Grip: Most spades have comfortable, straight handles. Some offer D-shaped grips for extra control.
- Fatigue: Using a spade reduces fatigue in hard ground, since you push down with your foot.
Shovel Ergonomics
- Lifting: Shovels are designed for scooping and lifting, so they can strain your back if used for digging in hard ground.
- Grip: D-shaped or shorter handles help with control when lifting soil.
- Fatigue: In soft soil, shovels are fast and efficient. In tough soil, they can cause more strain.
Tip: Switch between tools as needed to avoid repetitive strain. For example, dig with a spade, then remove soil with a shovel.
Credit: www.bch.org
Practical Comparison: Spade Vs Shovel In Real Tree Planting
Let’s compare how these tools perform in a common planting scenario—a new apple tree in a suburban backyard.
- Marking and Cutting the Hole: The spade’s sharp, flat blade cuts a perfect circle through grass and soil. You can control the diameter and depth easily.
- Digging Through Roots: If you hit small roots, the spade slices them cleanly. A shovel tends to bounce off or tear roots.
- Removing the Soil: Once the outline is done, you loosen the soil with the spade, then use the shovel to scoop and carry it away.
- Shaping the Sides: The spade trims the sides neatly. A shovel leaves irregular, sloped sides that can collapse.
- Backfilling: The shovel moves the soil back quickly; the spade tamps it down and helps you firm the ground.
Result: The combination of both tools gives the best results, but if you have to choose one, the spade is more essential for proper planting.
Durability And Maintenance
Quality matters. A poorly made tool can break or damage your tree roots.
Digging Spade
- Blade Material: Stainless or carbon steel resists bending and stays sharp.
- Handle: Wood handles are traditional and comfortable but can rot. Fiberglass handles resist weather, but can be slippery.
- Care: Clean after use, oil the blade, and store dry to avoid rust.
Shovel
- Blade Material: Look for thick steel or strong aluminum for durability.
- Handle: D-shaped handles are easy to grip, but check for solid construction.
- Care: Rinse off soil, dry before storing, and check for cracks.
Extra tip: Beginners often forget to check the welds where the blade meets the handle. Weak welds can cause breakage during tough digging.
Credit: www.dhgate.com
Cost Comparison: Spade Vs Shovel
Prices vary by brand, material, and quality, but there are general trends:
| Tool | Entry-Level Price | High-Quality Price | Expected Lifespan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Digging Spade | $20–$40 | $60–$120 | 10+ years (with care) |
| Shovel | $15–$30 | $40–$90 | 8–12 years (with care) |
Investing in a high-quality spade can pay off over decades, especially if you plant trees regularly.
Common Mistakes When Choosing Or Using These Tools
Many first-time planters make costly mistakes:
- Using the Wrong Tool for the Job: Trying to dig a precise hole with a shovel leads to frustration and poor results.
- Buying Cheap Tools: Low-quality spades bend or break, while cheap shovels can be uncomfortable.
- Ignoring Handle Length: Short handles increase back strain; choose a handle that matches your height.
- Not Maintaining Tools: Rusty or dull blades are harder to use and can damage roots.
- Overworking with One Tool: Switching between a spade and shovel prevents fatigue and improves efficiency.
Practical advice: Test the tool in-store if possible. Check the balance, weight, and grip. A comfortable tool encourages good technique.
Factors To Consider Before Buying
Not all spades and shovels are equal. Here’s what really matters:
- Soil Type: Heavy clay requires a strong, sharp spade. Sandy soil is easier with a shovel.
- Tree Size: Large root balls need bigger, deeper holes—choose a sturdy, full-size spade.
- User Strength and Height: Lightweight tools are best for beginners or those with limited strength.
- Handle Comfort: Wooden handles are warmer in cold weather; fiberglass is lighter and weather-resistant.
- Foot Treads: Spades with a wide tread are more comfortable for pressing down with your boot.
Extra insight: Many beginners overlook the importance of a non-slip grip. Wet conditions can make smooth handles dangerous.
Tree Species And Planting Location: Does It Affect Tool Choice?
Yes—different trees and sites may require different tools.
- Urban Planting: Street trees often face compacted soils—choose a robust spade.
- Orchards: Multiple trees mean efficiency is key. Use a spade for digging and a shovel for moving soil.
- Rocky Ground: A narrow, strong spade helps work around stones.
- Wet or Flooded Areas: Shovels with drainage holes can help remove muddy soil.
Example: Planting a pine tree in soft forest soil is faster with a shovel, but a maple in tough clay needs a spade.
Safety Considerations
Tree planting can be physically demanding. Use these safety tips:
- Use Proper Technique: Keep your back straight, bend at the knees, and use your legs.
- Wear Gloves: Protect hands from blisters and splinters.
- Watch for Underground Utilities: Call before you dig in urban areas.
- Store Tools Safely: Don’t leave spades or shovels lying flat where someone could trip.
Environmental Impact
Quality tools last longer and reduce waste. Stainless steel spades and shovels with wooden handles are often recyclable. Avoid tools with plastic parts that break easily.
Sustainability tip: Some brands offer tools made from recycled steel or sustainably harvested wood.
Which Tool Is Best For You?
- If you only buy one tool for planting trees, choose a digging spade with a strong, straight blade.
- For the fastest and best results, use both: Spade for digging and shaping, shovel for moving soil.
- Match the tool to your soil type, tree size, and physical strength.
Expert Opinions And Research
Horticulture experts and universities agree: the right tool improves survival rates for young trees. According to a study by the Royal Horticultural Society, trees planted with vertical-sided holes (spade-dug) develop stronger, deeper root systems compared to those planted with sloped-sided holes (shovel-dug). You can read more about this research at the Royal Horticultural Society.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is The Main Difference Between A Digging Spade And A Shovel?
The main difference is the blade shape and purpose. A digging spade has a flat, straight blade for cutting and digging, while a shovel has a curved or pointed blade for scooping and moving material.
Can I Plant A Tree With Only A Shovel?
Yes, you can, but it’s harder to make a clean, straight-sided hole. Your tree may not root as well, and the job will take more effort, especially in tough soil.
How Do I Choose The Right Size Spade Or Shovel?
Choose a tool that matches your height and strength. The handle should reach about chest height. For spades, a blade about 10–12 inches long is common. For shovels, pick one with a comfortable grip and a bowl size you can lift easily.
Are There Special Spades Or Shovels For Tree Planting?
Yes, some brands offer tree planting spades—these have extra-strong blades and foot treads. However, a standard, high-quality digging spade works well for most trees.
How Do I Keep My Digging Tools In Good Condition?
Clean the blade after each use, dry thoroughly, oil metal parts to prevent rust, and store in a dry place. Check for loose handles or cracks before each use.
Planting a tree is more than just digging a hole—it’s about giving your tree the best start possible. With the right tool in hand and the knowledge from this guide, you’re well-equipped for success. Happy planting!
Sabbir Ahmed is an experienced gardener and the lead voice behind GardenToolsGuide.com, where he combines over 15 years of hands-on horticultural expertise with a passion for sustainable cultivation. Specializing in organic soil health and permaculture, Sabbir has dedicated his career to testing and refining the best methods for maintaining thriving green spaces. His mission is to simplify the complexities of gardening by providing practical, tool-focused advice that helps fellow enthusiasts—from beginners to seasoned pros—grow nutrient-dense food and beautiful landscapes with efficiency and ease.